In all honesty, William and Mary was not my first choice. However, it was the first college that I visited and I never had it far from mind while visiting other schools (Duke, Yale, Princeton, Wake Forest, etc.). I had always wanted to go to Duke University, in Durham, NC, in part because I was, and continue to be, a huge supporter of their men's basketball team. When I visited the school, I fell in love, and upon learning about their strong emphasis on community service work, I felt that it would be a great fit for me. However, after getting jerked around a bit by the admissions office (waitlisted twice, off of early decision), I decided to look elsewhere for school.
My first impressions of William and Mary were how beautiful the campus was. It was exactly how I had pictured a university to be: brick walkways, huge green quad in the middle of campus, old brick buildings, with ivy growing on some of them. The student body was the right size, and they had strong departments in things that I was (at the time) considering majoring in, in English and History. The people all seemed friendly, and it didn't seem to be monochromatic in a way that was deterring or unsettling. And of course, William and Mary has a strong reputation for its academics, being consistently named one of the best universities and public universities in America, as well as being one of the 8 members of the so-called "Public Ivies."
When it came time to eventually choose a university, I had many great options to choose from, but ultimately, it came down to a visceral feeling I had when visiting William and Mary. Despite the fact that other schools I was accepted to may have had stronger programs, or a more vibrant night life, or better sports teams, I felt instinctually that I could see myself wandering William and Mary's campus much more easily than at any other school. Sometimes, I have to do a reality check and realize that I am now one of the students that walks the storied paths surrounding the Sunken Gardens that high schoolers on tours of the College stare at while taking their own tour. It's an incredible feeling, and good to know that I made the right choice in selecting William and Mary.