How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

College Search

Our counselors answered:

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

Reecy Aresty
College Admissions/Financial Aid Expert & Author Payless For College, Inc.

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

You want to be as selective as feasibly possible, unless you don't care - & that would surely be a poor choice! Nothing's perfect, and you'll have to make the best of it, but you don't want to be miserable doing it, so plan well in advance or suffer the consequences. Remember, it's you who's doing the selecting, not some 3rd party!

Bill Pruden
Head of Upper School, College Counselor Ravenscroft School

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

Selectivity is more about their evaluation of you and your fellow applicants than it is about your evaluating the school. Selectivity is about the number who apply and what the school’s needs are. It is not a measure of the educational experience that a student may have. The fact that an accepted applicant was one of 10 who could have gone does not mean they are better than if they were one of four. The important number is 1—you, and whether the school serves your needs and aspirations tn. Selectivity is about external things–focus on the internal ones–you.

Nancy Milne
Owner Milne Collegiate Consulting

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

For some students and families it is all about selectivity. That is fine if that is the type of environment you will be comfortable in for the next 4 years. Other applicants may not want to buy in to the pressure to succeed and feel there is more to the college experience than prestige. Be cautious when noting statistics put out by the recruitment folks. They are obviously only going for a positive spin and if you dig a little deeper you might find they haven't shared the whole picture. Do your own homework and pay attention to what feels right to you.

Benjamin Caldarelli
Partner Princeton College Consulting, LLC

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

Selectivity is important to consider when determining if a school is a good match. It can be misleading however, since many schools are very self selective. Therefore, a school with a 10 percent admission rate is not necessarily better than a school with a 20 percent admission rate.

Kathleen Harrington
Owner New Jersey College Consulting

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

When conducting your research on chosen colleges you must be aware of what the average acceptance rate...the lower the percentage accepted, the more selective the school. When applying, understand your chances of getting in to highly selected schools. A well balanced list that contacts a well balanced list of highly selective and selective schools, given you meet a majority of the criteria, will most likely lead to a successful college application process.

Rana Slosberg
Owner Slosberg College Solutions LLC

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

When applying to colleges, it is important for you to understand the school's selectivity. The more selective a college is, the less likely it is that you will get accepted even if you are a qualified candidate. Selectivity is not a measure of how good a fit the college is. it is a measure of how likely it is that you will receive the "fat" envelope with an acceptance letter.

Angela Conley
College Admission Expert VentureForth

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

Selective colleges are those with more than 50 applicants for every available seat. This simply means they are more selective in choosing their class because their research has shown which characteristics and preparation characterize successful graduates from their institutions. Just as colleges researched the metrics for successful students as they identify those they will admit, those applying should do the same. Applicants should selectively discern the intellectual and social environments where they are best suited to be challenged. In the midst of challenge, students and families should also identify which environments are suited to growing them from who they are, to who they hope to become. It is a fit and match process and with 4000 colleges and universities, those who do the research can make an informed choice. I tell students find the place that feels good on your mindset, your pocketbook and your aims. The answer varies based on your beginning and the experiences you bring to the enterprise that is college.

Zahir Robb
College Counselor The Right Fit College

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

Selectivity of schools will help you understand the number of applicants that are accepted. I have heard stories of schools encouraging a larger number of applicants through promotions, but I would like to think that most numbers are genuine. The selectivity of a school will generally drive up its admissions criteria as the more applicants that apply, the more selective a school can be. Just as with any club or new restaurant, this increases the interest in a school and a cyclical process begins. This means nothing of its quality of education or fit for you, so use this number with caution.

Ronald Harris

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

Increased selectivity means better students are going to all colleges, broadening your choice of schools with a high achieving student population.The number of applicants is rising, making admissions more competitive. Students and parents should consider a range of schools, rather than focusing on a specific institution.

Dr Sharon
Associate Professor and Program Director of the International Business Bachelor Program Friends University

How important is selectivity in evaluating colleges?

If you want to attend a prestigious college, then selectivity is important. These are institutions that can command high tuition and turn away many applicants. However, there is a college out there for everyone, you just have to find it. If you choose not to cater to the whims or trends of student recruitment, you can find an institution that will fit the kind of person you are and your interests and values. On the other hand, sometimes being a unique character who doesn't say and do what every other candidate says and does can be the one thing that sets you apart from the rest of the flock.