What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

College Search

Our counselors answered:

What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

Rod Bugarin
Former Admissions Officer Columbia, Brown, and Wesleyan University

What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

Here is my video response to the question.

Suzan Reznick
Independent Educational Consultant The College Connection

One with a strong academic profile

While colleges do consider many factors in making admit decisions: such as geographic, racial and religious diversity, ability to pay, talent( in sports/arts etc) demonstrated interest in a campus and legacy. The key factor for all schools would be your likelihood of being academically successful if you were to be accepted. In order to determine this- your HS transcripts is carefully evaluated, both as to your grades and the level of challenge ( i.e. AP/Honors/IB Classes). After the transcripts, your test scores are given the most attention. Colleges will list the average GPA and SAT scores for their most recent freshman class. Check and see if your academic profile comes close to who they accepted last year, to determine if you have a chance at admissions.

Erin Avery
Certified Educational Planner Avery Educational Resources, LLC

Walking the Plank of Selective Colleges

Selective colleges rely on numbers to assess the competition as fairly as possible. Test scores will matter more often at selective colleges as well as grades, course selection and rigor. If you have a "hook" (not the "arrrr" kind) meaning something that distinguishes you as uber desirable such as athletic prowess, musical talent, etc, in addition to the numbers, you may consider more selective colleges. But ultimately, the cream rises to the top, and if you are the cream, you will be recognized as such. The Avery Advantage suggests working closely with your guidance counselor and/or consultant to establish a balanced list of colleges to which to apply. Inability to manage one's expectations is often the fatal flaw of the high achieving student. Consider yourself warned, Matey.

Nancy Milne
Owner Milne Collegiate Consulting

Highly selective school applicant profile

If you are someone who thrives in an atmosphere with a strong academic press, then please consider the selectivity of the school. If you enjoy being surrounded by others with a serious commitment to their education, you want to be looking at a selective school. If you have a strong transcript, demonstrating rigor in the curriculum; then considering a highly selective school has merit. Please don't bother applying if you are just trying to earn the "badge" of acceptance or the coursework expectations seem overwhelming before you've even begun. If you are interested in an opportunity to work closely with a faculty member on a project or in a lab, this may be the environment for you.

Patricia Krahnke
President/Partner Global College Search Associates, LLC

What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

Short Answer: A perfect student (or as close to perfect as it is possible to get) Detailed Answer: As I mentioned in a previous post, when I visited Yale in the Spring, the counselor I spoke with told me in no uncertain terms, “We only take the top students.” As it happens, I was there to see her about a student I am working with who is brilliant -- AND the family has legacy. I did not tell her I was a consultant; I could have been the parent – and a wealthy one, at that. At the very least, in this instance, I was representing one. So what did this counselor do? She blew me off. Like, totally. She made it quite clear to me that students considering Yale must have: 1. An academic record that is consistently As and A+s in as many AP courses as possible 2. Exhausted all the academic options at their school and pursued college courses if there were no more academic challenges at their school 3. Perfect SATs (or squeakingly close) 4. No break in the academic flow and no grade dips of any kind 5. No gap year And that’s it – for Yale. Needless to say, I am encouraging this student to seek entrance to a college that is more worthy of not only his brilliance, but of his spirit and his mental adventurousness. When I experience a dehumanizing experience such as that in an admissions office, I am pretty sure that is the experience the college or university promotes throughout its ranks, and that is unacceptable. That’s why I like visiting colleges incognito – I want to experience first-hand the way they treat people. If I don’t like the way they treat me, then I’m not going to like the way they treat the young people I have the privilege of helping find success and fulfillment in their lives. Now, other similarly selective colleges have more of an interest in who you are as a human being and whether or not your personal philosophies and academic interests fit their community. They, too, are seeking the top academic students, but their definition of a “top student” has more range and flexibility than simply a set of numbers. For example, an Oberlin or a Swarthmore is highly selective – they look for top students, as well, but you have to have more going for you than simply a great academic record. You don’t have to dig too far into information about these types of colleges to see that they value character and integrity. A visit to these colleges conveys this even more. One more thing: If you are a low income student seeking entrance to a selective college, if your numbers are fantastic, and your character and interests fit the spirit of the college, they will probably try to find money for you to attend. But even the elite colleges are worried about their budgets these days, so they may be leaning toward admitting students who can pay out of pocket, even though they may state in their marketing materials that they have a “need blind” as regards admissions.

Bill Pruden
Head of Upper School, College Counselor Ravenscroft School

What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

Applicants to highly selective schools should be highly motivated students sporting strong records that include something distinctive on top of their extremely strong basic foundation. When the most selective schools have the luxury of selecting a single applicant from every 8 or 9 highly qualified ones (yes, last year Harvard as well as other of its Ivy brethren had an acceptance rate of less than 10%) they review, the applicant needs to have something that makes them stand out from the rest. At the same time an array of great, but not one of a kind accomplishments, can also yield success but students need to recognize that this process is, in many ways, an introduction to real world competition at an extremely high level. If you are determined to apply, do it, recognize the competitive nature of the process. You should not apply simply because a place is selective. Rather, you apply because of what it offers, recognizing that a part of why it is so selective is because what it offers is so valuable and thus so coveted.

Reecy Aresty
College Admissions/Financial Aid Expert & Author Payless For College, Inc.

What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

A student at the top of their class, but only if those schools have the particular curriculum the student wishes to pursue.

Benjamin Caldarelli
Partner Princeton College Consulting, LLC

What kind of student should be looking at a highly selective school?

Students who have a passion for learning and responsible citizenship will be good candidates for admission at highly selective schools. Cultivation of an athletic or artistic talent will make them especially desirable.

Tam Warner Minton
Consultant College Adventures

Academic Rigor

The kind of student who should be looking at a highly selective college is a student who is very academic, with excellent test scores, and who is ranked highly within their class. Interesting extracurriculars and experiences help as well. But remember this: highly selective colleges (acceptance rate below 20%) receive applications from perfectly qualified students, but they still only accept a fraction of them. There will be plenty of National Merit Scholars and Valedictorians in the applicant pool, and many of them will be declined. There are certainly no guarantees, and rigor can be found outside of the highly selective school bracket.

王文君 June Scortino
President IVY Counselors Network

academically prepared and competitive for admissions advantages

if your school has the first class counseling services open to students, you should consider highly selective schools to gain competitive advantages for admissions. if you are not going to apply for financial aid, please use early decision strategy for admisisons, highly selective schools offer early decision with better acceptence rate. if you are strong in academics and do not have access to first class counseling services, you should consider highly selective schools through regular decision and pay attention to the list of schools to apply. the common mistakes made by the majority of middle class students are apply too many similar schools based on brand name recognition and nothing outstanding other than academics.